What I Learned Watching Wisconsin Count its Votes

Democracy is complicated. Counting the votes is surprisingly meticulous.

Our job was straightforward: observe, ask questions, and verify that every vote was accounted for.

Out of more than 16,000 votes, the number of discrepancies was remarkably small—only four or five.

The post-election canvass is one of several interlocking safeguards in Wisconsin law.

Nobody was there to score partisan points; we were all there to ensure the count was right.

by Sheldon Rampton

As Wisconsin prepares for the upcoming election, I find myself thinking about four hours I spent watching democracy at work. There were no stirring speeches, cheering crowds, or dramatic revelations. Mostly, there were spreadsheets, incident reports, and people carefully checking numbers.

And that was exactly what made it reassuring.

Following the spring election, I participated for the first time in what is known as the canvass—the official process of reviewing election returns to verify that votes were counted accurately. I served as a volunteer observer for the Democratic Party in Columbia County, alongside another Democrat, Margo Miller. Two Republican observers were also present. Presiding over the proceedings was County Clerk Lisa Black.

Our job was straightforward: observe, ask questions, and verify that every vote was accounted for.

A total of 16,568 ballots were cast in Columbia County that April. Over four hours, we went through returns municipality by municipality, comparing reported totals with machine tapes and poll books. The clerk’s office had assembled result sheets alongside incident logs kept by poll workers documenting anything unusual on Election Day.

Out of more than 16,000 votes, the number of discrepancies was remarkably small—only four or five. Reviewing them offered a window into how the system handles the unexpected.

In a couple of instances, a voting machine had jammed. That is usually just an inconvenience, but if a poll worker feeds a ballot through again without checking whether it was already scanned, an overcount can occur. On social media, that might be framed as dark evidence of election fraud. In the canvass room, it was simply an accounting problem to be investigated, documented, and reconciled against the paper trail.

We also encountered human complications. One involved a man who had moved across district lines and accidentally voted in both places before poll workers caught the error. Another involved a voter whose spouse grew combative when reminded of voter-assistance rules, tore up her own ballot in frustration, and stormed out (her husband finished voting calmly; her shredded ballot was set aside and properly excluded).

There were also absentee ballots from voters who had died between mailing their ballots and Election Day. Under Wisconsin law, those votes cannot be counted. The clerk’s office had segregated them in sealed envelopes, complete with printed obituaries. There was something poignant about seeing citizens exercise their civic duty in their final days, and equally poignant seeing election officials meticulously follow the statute to exclude them.

The takeaway wasn’t that mistakes and oddities happened. When thousands of people interact with equipment and rules, anomalies are inevitable. What mattered was that every incident was logged, investigated, and reconciled under public observation.

The post-election canvass is one of several interlocking safeguards in Wisconsin law. Poll workers maintain contemporaneous logs. Ballots are sealed and secured. Municipalities report to counties, and bipartisan boards verify the numbers before any result is certified. None of the discrepancies we found would have altered any outcome, but everyone treated single-digit variances with total seriousness.

Equally striking was the atmosphere in the room. The Republican and Democratic observers worked together without friction. One of the Republican observers had previously worked with my wife, and we chatted pleasantly during breaks. Nobody was there to score partisan points; we were all there to ensure the count was right.

I observed the canvass again following the August primary. The methodical review was identical, but the most memorable detail had nothing to do with the candidates: a staff member in the county clerk’s office had been nine months pregnant on Election Day. Despite being on the verge of delivery, she worked through the night administering the election, going into labor before the shift was done. During our canvass, Clerk Black received a text confirming both mother and baby were doing well.

That kind of dedication rarely makes the news. Election workers usually receive public attention only when someone has a grievance. Yet they manage complex legal procedures, long hours, and occasionally difficult voters with remarkable patience.

Public debate today often fixates on whether elections can be trusted. Oversight is vital, and questioning procedures is healthy. But there is a crucial difference between acknowledging that human error occurs and assuming that errors equal fraud.

What I witnessed in Columbia County was a resilient system designed specifically to catch human fallibility. A paper jam or an arithmetic mismatch is not a conspiracy. It is reality meeting procedure. What matters is whether the safeguards work.

Real election integrity does not rely on blind trust. It relies on transparent verification: diligent poll workers, meticulous clerks, strict paper trails, and citizens from across the political spectrum willing to sit in a room together and check the math.

From where I was sitting, democracy looked careful, transparent, and remarkably sound.

[Sheldon Rampton is a Portage, WI resident, author of seven books, including a New York Times bestseller, and a technology professional with decades of experience in journalism, public affairs, and nonprofit organizations. He volunteers with the Columbia County Democrats, helping with communications, website development, and election oversight.]

Previous
Previous

Check the Calendar!

Next
Next

Photo Gallery: Monthly Meeting, Sat. Oct. 10